The Why, What, Where, When, and How It Was Achieved DR. TIM BALL Contents Preface Dedication Human Caused Global Warming The Biggest Deception In History Why? What Is Normal? 97% Consensus (The Actual # is 0.3%) Paradigm Shift: Environmentalism Exploitation of Complexity Moving Goalposts Lack of Knowledge of History of Climate Change Ice Sheets Just 18,000 Years Ago Sea Level Change Northern Hemisphere Temperature for Last 10,000 Years – the Holocene Optimum The Instrumental Global Temperature Record IPCC Temperature Projections Versus Reality Computer Models: Gospel In Gospel Out (GIGO) IPCC Computer Models: Average of Averages Inability to Forecast Weather and Climate Exploitation of Public Lack of Knowledge and Emotions Measures of Public Climate Knowledge Climategate Cover Up Misinformation About Severe Weather Arctic Ice: A Classic Example of Exploitation What Is Normal for Annual Arctic Ice Melt You Need a Threatened Animal to Raise Emotional Quotient The Greenhouse Effect Deliberate Deception of Public Perception Early Conflicting Evidence Rewriting History–The Troubling Diagram CO2 and Temperature Over 600 Million Years Adjusting the Data to Prove the Hypothesis Stations Chosen to Create the Record Data Manipulation Adjusting the Data to Fit the Hypothesis Changing the IPCC Reports Santer’s Insertions Troublesome Graphs The Actual Diagram Omissions: It’s The Sun, Stupid The Milankovitch Effect The Cosmic Theory Historic Evidence The Circumpolar Vortex Social and Economic Damage WHO? Maurice Strong John Holdren Al Gore WHAT? Underlying Motivation: Over-population Overpopulation Claims in the 20th Century The World is Not Overpopulated! HOW Achieving The Goal Bureaucracy Organizational Chart: A Bureaucrat’s Delight How Politicians and Bureaucrats Deflect, But Retain Control Structure of The IPCC How So Few Fooled So Many Evidence of The Political Objective The Precautionary Principle Discussion A Few Important Definitions General References Preface There is a big problem once you decide to use science for a political agenda, especially if the scientific hypothesis is untested. If it fails when tested going forward, the only options are to admit it doesn’t work or make the evidence fit the story. The people who formulated the human caused global warming hypothesis chose the latter and the deception began. This is a handbook written for the general public providing information that they don’t hear from their government or most of the media about how the greatest deception in history occurred over the last many years. It is the story of how and why the global warming deception was achieved. The world has not warmed for over 20 years, yet carbon dioxide (CO2) levels continue to rise in complete contradiction to what all governments are saying. And that in itself should make people ask a lot more questions than those identified in the book. This book explains the entire story of how and why global warming, the claim that human activities produce CO2 that causes temperature increase, as a scientific issue was exploited for a political agenda. It is presented in the form of a criminal or journalistic investigation answering the basic questions, Why, Who, What, Where, When, and How. Footnotes or references are not included, but all the material is available on the internet. If the reader wants expansion of any section or reference material, it is available in my book The Deliberate Corruption of Climate Science shown at the end of this book and on my website at drtimball.com. Over the years, my challenge to the government version of global warming became increasingly problematic. Neither the government nor the environmentalists could say I wasn’t qualified. I am blessed with an ability to teach and explain complex ideas so people can understand. This talent was honed by teaching a Canadian science credit course to arts students for 25 years. The attacks against me include death threats, large amounts of false information about my qualifications posted on web sites, including Wikipedia, and three law suits, two of which are still pending. Most people cannot believe that such things occur in a supposedly democratic open society. If you want to test the idea, just say to people that you don’t accept the idea that humans are causing global warming. You will be amazed at the vehement reaction you get from the majority of people, all of whom know nothing about the science. We live in the delusion that we know what is going on, but we don’t. Author and medical doctor Michael Crichton described the problem in the opening paragraph of a 2003 speech he gave in San Francisco. I have been asked to talk about what I consider the most important challenge facing mankind, and I have a fundamental answer. The greatest challenge facing mankind is the challenge of distinguishing reality from fantasy, truth from propaganda. Perceiving the truth has always been a challenge, but in the information age (or as I think of it, the disinformation age) it takes on a special urgency and importance. In this book I am not asking you to believe what I am telling you; people are tired of being told what to think. I am simply setting out facts you have not been told by the government or environmentalists, so you can ask yourself why. Then, put together what government and environmentalists and the mainstream media tell you, and draw your own conclusions. I often begin a presentation by saying “Morning.” Then I point out that I didn’t say “Good morning” followed by “Make up your own mind.” Dedication This book is dedicated to my wife, Marty, and my sons, Dave and Tim Jr. My pursuit of the truth and a willingness to speak out triggered Voltaire’s warning. “It is dangerous to be right in matters where established men are wrong.” Unfortunately, members of my family were also victims of the attempts to silence me. For that, I am forever grateful for their unending support and the sacrifices they made. Human Caused Global Warming - dr. Tim Ball ( PDF Book ) Credentials 1 CURRICULUM VITAE: Dr Timothy F Ball Date of Birth: 5 November 1938 Citizenship: Canadian Post-Secondary Education B.A., (Honours), Gold Medal Winner, University of Winnipeg, 1970 M.A., University of Manitoba, 1971 Ph.D. (Doctor of Science), Queen Mary College, University of London (England), 1982 Career 1996 - Environmentalist, Public Speaker, Consultant, Author, columnist. 1988-96 Professor, University of Winnipeg 1984-88 Associate Professor, University of Winnipeg 1982-84 Assistant Professor, University of Winnipeg 1977-78 Acting Dean of Students 1972-82 Lecturer, Department of Geography, University of Winnipeg 1971-72 Instructor, Geography Department, University of Winnipeg 1964-68 Air Crew and Operations Officer, Search and Rescue, Arctic and Western Canada, Winnipeg, Manitoba 1962-64 Operations Officer, OTU, 429 Squadron, Summerside, P.E.I. 1960-62 Air Crew, Navigation, Electronics, 415 Squadron, Summerside, P.E.I. Special Academic or Professional Honours Gold Medal, Honours Geography, University of Winnipeg Twice Runner-Up for the Clifford Robson Award for Teaching Excellence Clifford Robson Award for Teaching Excellence Atchison Award for Community Service Graduate Fellowship, University of Manitoba Humboldt Award, Geography Department, University of Winnipeg Research Fellow George Morris Centre Paul Harris Fellow Rotary Canada Professional Activities Outside the University Founder and Director, Rupert's Land Research Centre 1980 - 1996 Member, Manitoba Water Commission 1980 - 1996 Past President, Manitoba Social Science Teachers Association Past Editor, Manitoba Social Science Teachers Journal Past Chairman, Canadian Committee on Climatic Fluctuation and Man 2 Member, Social Science Curriculum Advisory Committee, Department of Education Former Board Member, The Forks Development Heritage Advisory Board Former Board Member, Urban Ideas Centre Former Board Member, Western Canada Pictorial Index Former Chair, City of Winnipeg's Advisory Committee on Hazardous Waste Technical Advisor to the Canadian Cattlemen’s Association Former Chair Assiniboine River Management Advisory Board Former Board Member of British Columbia Agriculture in the Classroom Significant Publications "The Nitty Gritty of Winnipeg Air", Prairie Forum, Fall 1977, pp. 32-47 "Comparative Air Quality in Urban and Suburban Environments of Winnipeg", Manitoba Environmental Research Council Annual Publication, Project #33, 1975, p. 15 "An Assessment of the Urban Heat Island as a Potential Energy", Manitoba Environmental Research Council Annual Publication, Project #34, 1975, p. 12 "As Cold As Ever I Knew It. Manitoba Climate for the Last 200 Years" Historical and Scientific Society of Manitoba Transactions, Series III, Number 33, 1976-77, pp. 61-66 "Analysis of Historical Evidence of Climatic Change in Western and Northern Canada," Syllogeus, Climatic Change in Canada 2, Editor, C.R. Harington, National Museum of Natural Sciences, Ottawa, 1981, Vol. 33, pp. 78-96 Climatic Change in Central Canada: A Preliminary Analysis of Weather Information from Hudson's Bay Company Forts at York Factory and Churchill Factory, 1714-1850, unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, University of London, England, p. 480 "The Migration of Geese as an Indicator of Climate Change in the Southern Hudson Bay Region Between 1715 and 1851", Climatic Change, Vol. 5, No. 1, 1983a, pp. 83-93 "Climate and History: A Connection that Cannot be Ignored", History and Social Science Teacher, Vol. 19, No. 4, May 1984, pp. 205-214 Selected Climatological Data from Hudson's Bay Company Records for the Period 1718- 1939 at Churchill, Manitoba, Environment Canada, Downsview, Ontario, 1984, p. 132 Selected Climatological Data from Hudson's Bay Company Records for the Period 1714- 1913 at York Factory, Manitoba", Environment Canada, Downsview, Ontario, 1984, p. 174 3 "Report on a Colloquium Held at the University of Winnipeg", Manitoba Culture and Heritage, Vol. 2, No. 2, Summer 1984, pp. 11-12 "A Dramatic Change in the General Circulation on the West Coast of Hudson Bay in 1760 A.D.: Synoptic Evidence Based on Historic Records", Syllogeus Climatic Change in Canada 5: Critical Periods in the Quaternary Climatic History of Northern North America, Editor, C.R. Harington, National Museums of Canada, 1985, Vol. 55, pp. 219-229 "Preliminary Analysis of Early Instrumental Temperature Records from York Factory and Churchill Factory", Syllogeus Climate Change in Canada 3 Project on Climatic Change in Canada During the Past 20,000 Years, Editor, C.R. Harington, National Museums of Canada, Vol. 49, 1983b, pp. 203-220 "The Hudson's Bay Company Records as a Source of Climatic Information", Rendezvous: Selected Papers of the Fourth Annual Fur Trade Conference, Minnesota Historical Society, Editor, Thomas C. Buckley, 1984, pp. 43-51 "Changes in the General Circulation of the Atmosphere in the 1760's at Churchill and York Factory, Manitoba", North Dakota Academy of Sciences Symposium Papers, Vol. 38, pp. 16-18 "Observations of the Transit of Venus at Prince of Wales Fort in 1769", The Beaver Outfit 315:2, Autumn 1984, pp. 48-59 "Instrumental Temperature Records at Two Sites in Central Canada: 1768 to 1910" Climatic Change 1984, Vol. 6, pp. 39-56 "Historical Evidence and Climatic Implications of a Shift in the Boreal Forest Tundra Transition in Central Canada", Climatic Change 1986, Vol. 7, pp. 218-229 "A Report to the Pearse Commission Federal Inquiry on Water Resources", Manitoba Water Commission, October 1984, p. 13 "The Boreal-Tundra Transition" in Physical Geography, Editor, William Marsh, Harper and Rowe, New York, 1986, pp. 324-325 "An Early Energy Crisis: The Importance of Woodcutting at Churchill in the Early Years of the Fur Trade", Horizon Canada, 1985, Vol. 5, No. 60, pp. 1436-1440. "Measurement of Climate in Early Canada", Horizon Canada, 1985, Vol. 3, No. 27, pp. 562-573 "Teaching Weather and Climate: Some Topics that Should be Covered", Social Science Teachers Journal, Spring 1985, Vol. 12, No. 2, pp. 13-15 4 "The Climate of Antarctica", Manitoba Social Science Teachers Journal, Spring 1986, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 28-31 "Long-term Climate Trends and Agriculture on the Prairies", Proceedings of the First Ministers Conference on the Environment, Calgary, Alberta, 1986, pp. 17-26 "Evidence of Climate Change at Trengwainton Gardens, Cornwall, England", Weather, June 1987, Vol. 42, No. 6, pp. 176-180 "Timber", The Beaver, 1987, Vol. 67:2, pp. 45-57 "Fur Trade Gardens", The Prairie Garden, 1987, Vol. 48, pp. 117-120 "Historical and Instrumental Evidence of Extreme Climatic Conditions in Central Canada: 1770-1820", Annales Geophysicae, Proceedings of the Annual Geophysical Society General Assembly, Bologna, March 1988, p. 84 "Company Town", The Beaver, June-July 1988, Vol. 68:3, pp. 43-52 Fundamentals of Physical Geography, Copp Clarke and Pitman, First Edition, Toronto, 1989, p. 594 "Water: The Resource Issue of the 21st Century in North America", Canadian Dimensions, Fall 1988, Vol. 22, No. 6, pp. 8-14 "Manitoba Climate: Past, Present and Future", Technical and Scientific Papers of the Conference for Agricultural Professionals, 1988, Manitoba Agri-Forum, Winnipeg, pp. 134-139 "Dauphin Lake, Manitoba: Death of a Prairie Lake?", Manitoba Social Science Teachers Journal, Vol. 15:2, 1988, pp. 11-23" "Lifeblood of a City", Manitoba Social Science Teachers Journal, Vol. 15:2, 1988, pp. 28-43 "Manitoba Climate: Its Impact on Agriculture, Past, Present and Future", in Proceedings 2nd Sol and Elsie Sinclair Farm Management Seminar Fund Series, 1988, Faculty of Agricultural Economics, University of Manitoba "Agriculture in the Classroom - A Report", Manitoba Social Science Teachers Journal Vol. 15:2, 1998, pp. 25-28 "Historical and Instrumental Evidence: Central Canada, 1714-1850" in Climate Since 1500 A.D., Editors, Philip Jones and Raymond Bradley, Climatic Research Centre, University of East Anglia 5 "Global Warming; The Need for Objectivity", Bio-Joule, January 1990, Vol. 12.3, pp. "Global Warming: Fact or Misinformation", Canadian Dimension, April/May 1990, Vol. 24:3, pp. 22-26 "The Greenhouse Effect; the Need for Scientific and Social Responsibility", Proceedings of the Canadian Committee on Climatic Fluctuation and Man Conference, National Museum of Natural Sciences, Ottawa, January, 1990 "Stromness, Orkney Islands; A Town of the Fur Trade", Highlander, Chicago, Illinois, May, 1990, pp. 4-8 Geopolitics: Understanding GATT and Free Trade, Proceedings of the Conference on Managing Agriculture for Profit, Kananaskis, Alberta, 1991. Climate and Agriculture: An Update, Proceedings of the Conference on Managing Agriculture for Profit, Kananaskis, Alberta, 1991. The Impact of Climate Change on Sustainable Agriculture in Canada, 1991 Science Council of Canada, Queen's Printers, Ottawa, 114 p. “Climatic Change, Droughts and Their Social Impact: Central Canada, 1811-20, a classic example." In C.R.Harington (ed) The Year Without a Summer? World Climate in 1816. 1992, National Museum of Natural Sciences, Canadian Museum of Nature, Ottawa “The Year without a Summer: Its Impact on the Fur Trade and History of Western Canada." In C.R.Harington (ed) The Year Without a Summer? World Climate in 1816. 1992, National Museum of Natural Sciences, Canadian Museum of Nature, Ottawa Ball, T., Fossett, R., Dion, L., Marcotte, G.M., 1992, An Historical Overview of Aboriginal Lifestyles: The Churchill/Nelson Drainage Basin, Rupert's Land Research Centre, Report for Manitoba Hydro. p. 307. Briggs, Smithson and Ball., 1992 of Fundamentals of Physical Geography, Second Edition, Copp Clark and Pitman. Toronto. p. 604. "An Iconoclast's View of Climatic Change" Canadian Water Resources Journal, Vol. 17, No.2. 1992. Ball and Houston, 18th Century Naturalists of Hudson Bay, Mcgill/ Queens University Press, 2004 M.G. Dyck, W. Soon,, R.K. Baydack, D.R. Legates, S. Baliunas, T.F. Ball and L.O. Hancock, Polar bears of western Hudson Bay and climate change: Are warming spring air temperatures the “ultimate” survival control factor? Ecological Complexity September, 2007, p 73-84. 6 Ball., T.F. , Johnson, C., Hertzberg.,M., Olson.,J.A., Siddons.,A., Anderson.,C., Schreuder.,H., and O’Sullivan.,J. Slaying the Sky Dragon:Death of the Greenhouse Gas Theory., Stairway Press, Mount Vernon Washington. February 2011. PDF Book admin note dr Tim´ s sit is , how surprisingly, erased so that is my motivation to put his work back here. Just for the sake of it and just to piss off the dark side. Tim has left this world now for a few years so I think it is a good idea to keep his work alive. AS it is the big stick to hammer the whole planet on its knees. Obviously.